Best Soft Mattress For Side Sleepers (Hybrid, Pillow Top)

    best soft mattress for side sleepers

    In this article I’ll be reviewing the Brooklyn Sedona mattress. I’m going to give you my pros and cons.

    Many people believe that this is the best soft mattress for side sleepers.

    The Sedona hybrid is the newest model that Brooklyn Bedding launched nationally in August of 2020.

    This hybrid mattress is the most luxurious model of the main mattress line, but as such it carries the highest price tag.

    Let’s talk about what this bed feels like.

    How Brooklyn Sedona Mattress Feels

    best soft mattress for side sleepers

    When talking about the feel of a bed, it’s important to talk about the support level or firmness of it.

    On a scale of one to ten, with ten being the firmest, I give the Brooklyn Sedona a 5.5 out of ten.

    That’s actually a little bit to the softer side than what I was expecting. When you sit on it, you are sinking into this pillow top section of the mattress, with these softer foams on top.

    We’ll take a closer look at the materials used in the layers of the mattress later on.

    But this pillow top section does provide some soft comfort, some really nice pressure relief. Even when I’m lying on my back, weight evenly distributed, I can feel myself sink into the mattress just a little bit.

    If you are a back sleeper that really likes that softer feel, that likes to feel more enveloped in the bed, this could be a good choice for you.

    But if you’re looking for a firmer, more supportive mattress, it might not be the best idea to go with the Brooklyn Sedona.

    Rolling onto my side, this is where these softer foams really help. I generally like softer mattresses for side sleepers, so you get a little bit more sinking in the mattress.

    You don’t get that jammed up feeling at the shoulders. It helps you avoid some shoulder pain, pressure at the hips and things like that.

    We will take a closer look at pressure later on.

    I do want to say in general that I do recommend the Brooklyn Sedona to the side sleepers out there.

    Rolling around and changing positions, I do think there’s decent bounce to the mattress. It is a hybrid build, so there is pocketed coil support. I didn’t feel stuck in the mattress, I was able to change positions pretty easily.

    Rolling onto my stomach, I did feel my hips sinking into the mattress a bit too far for my liking.

    I don’t think that the Brooklyn Sedona has the proper support for the stomach sleepers out there. I think it’s going to put your back in a bad position for that specific sleep style. So just be careful of that.

    Overall I think if you are a bit on the heavier side, it might not have the proper support you’re looking for.

    Pressure Tests

    best soft hybrid mattress

    Instead of just taking my word on the feel of the Brooklyn Sedona, I run a few tests.

    The first one that I run is the pressure map test and basically I put a pressure map down on top of the mattress. The results range from blue, for low pressure, to red, for high pressure.

    On my back, weight is evenly distributed. I thought that this mattress was pretty comfortable while I was lying on my back. If you are someone that likes a softer mattress as a back sleeper, I think you’ll be happy here with the Brooklyn Sedona.

    But if you are looking for that firmer support, I don’t think that you’re going to get that here.

    Rolling onto my side, it does go up a little bit into the green range in the shoulder or hip area, but I think this is actually an acceptable amount of pressure that we’re seeing on the pressure map.

    I really like the Sedona for the side sleepers because that pillow top section has a lot of space you can sink into for some really nice pressure relief, some really nice comfort at the shoulders and the hips to avoid pain in those areas.

    And finally when I roll onto my stomach, there is blue across the board. However, it doesn’t really tell the whole story. I think the mattress is just a bit too soft for the stomach sleepers and that is blue because of the even weight distribution across my body.

    Bounce Test

    Next I tested to see how much bounce the mattress provides or mobility, are you going to feel stuck in the mattress as you’re rolling around changing positions.

    I got to say there was pretty low bounce when I did this portion of the test, but I didn’t really feel stuck in the mattress when I was changing positions. So it’s not going to have that traditional steel coil inner spring bounce to it that you might expect.

    But in my experience, I didn’t feel stuck in the mattress. However, you might feel something a little bit different because of those softer foams on top.

    Motion Transfer Test

    most comfortable soft mattress

    Next is the motion transfer test and basically it means if you share your bed with a partner, are you going to feel it on your side of the bed when they start to roll around and change positions.

    When I tested it, I drop a 10-pound steel ball from heights of 4, 8 and 12 inches. And where you might be sleeping, I put a seismometer that’s going to check to see how much disturbance transferred with each of those drops.

    And with each of those drops I saw a really low motion transfer, especially for a mattress with coils like this I was pretty impressed.

    So if you do share your bed with another sleeper, this could be a really nice option for you if you want to make sure that you sleep through the night.

    Edge Support

    Last but not least is the edge sport portion of the review.

    Basically this is checking to see if you sleep all the way to the end of the bed, are you going to have to worry about you feeling you’re collapsing, are you going to get this feeling of rolling out of the bed in the middle of the night or anything like that.

    I thought the edge support was okay and because there is a really tall pillow top of softer foams, you are going to push through those and that can make the edge feel a little bit unstable at times. But overall I thought it was fine.

    Materials Inside Brooklyn Sedona Mattress

    To give you a better idea of what the Brooklyn Sedona is all about, I’ve cut open the back of it to see the materials used in the layers.

    First I do want to talk about the cover of the mattress.

    It uses a phase change material, kind of woven, so it’s got this cool to the touch feeling. Really nice to defend against some heat trap right off the bat.

    It is also quilted with a little bit of foam, so it gives you some nice softness.

    Below that we have these foam layers.

    We have the comfort layer of the mattress which is a gel memory foam. It has slow response to pressure.

    I mentioned that it is a gel memory foam. Now, memory foam can be known for trapping a bit of body heat, so they’ve used that gel infusion to help draw heat away from the sleeper to help you sleep a little bit cooler throughout the night.

    This memory foam layer is followed up by another denser memory foam layer. It also has slow response.

    These two are going to give you that contouring feel around your body that memory foam is known for. Memory foam is great for pressure relief. That’s why I think this is a good mattress if you are suffering from shoulder pain.

    Below that we do have a thin layer of polyurethane foam. It’s got a bit of a quick response to pressure. What this is really doing is basically transitioning you from these softer memory foam layers that you’re sinking into, before you hit the support layer, these pocketed coils of the mattress.

    It’s either going to provide the support and bounce to the mattress. They are individually wrapped, which is going to help them move a bit more independently than your traditional steel coil inner spring mattress. That’s another thing that’s going to help with motion transfer.

    In total, the Sedona mattress is made up of 7 layers.

    Brooklyn Bedding Sedona mattress

    The first layer consists of 1 inch of polyfoam, designed for responsiveness and pressure relieving contour.

    Next, a 2-inch layer of gel infused memory foam is engineered to add supportive cradling while transferring heat away from your body.

    Another 1 inch layer of gel infused memory foam enhances the cooling and provides deep compression support.

    A 1 inch polyfoam layer eases the transition between the comfort system and the support core. This core is made of an eight inch layer of individually in cased coils.

    Finally, there’s a one inch layer of polyfoam to support the springs at the base of the mattress.

    Best Copper Infused Foam Mattress

    Comparing Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses

    Brooklyn Bedding makes a few other mattresses so I want to compare the Sedona against a few of their other models.

    First we have the Sedona versus the Brooklyn Signature. It’s Brooklyn Bedding’s flagship mattress.

    It uses a hybrid build of pocketed coils and Brooklyn Bedding’s proprietary TitanFlex foam. It has a medium firm feel that provides nice blend of support and comfort that will appeal to a wide range of sleepers.

    When I tested the Brooklyn Signature, I was really impressed by its ability to align my spine in a good position by supporting my hips and keeping them in line with my shoulders.

    I think back and side combination sleepers are really going to appreciate the feel of the Signature as well as the good bounce to the mattress that will keep them from feeling stuck as they roll around in bed.

    The Brooklyn Signature is a good mattress for couples for a few reasons. One that medium firm feel is a good compromise if you and your partner have different preferences on the field of the bed.

    Two, the Signature does a pretty good job of isolating motion transfers, so you won’t be woken up when they adjust position on their side of the bed.

    And three, the Signature has good edge support, so you won’t have to worry about rolling out of bed if you sleep towards the side of the mattress.

    Next we have the Sedona versus the Brooklyn Aurora mattress.

    While the Signature might be their flagship model, I would say the aurora is probably their most popular mattress.

    The Brooklyn Aurora is a hybrid bed, where every element of the construction was chosen to help sleep cool through the night.

    That cooling design starts with the phase change cover that has a cool to the touch feeling. Phase change material does a great job as a first line of defense against heat trap, but Brooklyn Bedding follows that up by using their CopperFlex and TitanFlex foams, which both do a good job of dissipating body heat to avoid trapping it and having you sleep cooler overall.

    Along with the great cooling benefits of the Aurora, it also has a nice soft feel to it, which is great for side sleepers to help avoid the jammed up feeling of shoulder pain that a firmer mattress can cause.

    I was really impressed with the Brooklyn Aurora’s ability to isolate motion transfer, so it could be another good choice for the couples if you both like softer mattresses.


    Brooklyn Bedding is really popular so there is a lot of questions about the brand. I want to answer a few of the more frequently asked questions.

    The first one is where is Brooklyn Bedding located? It might surprise you but Brooklyn Bedding is not located in Brooklyn, New York. It is actually located in Phoenix, Arizona.

    They actually own their own factory out there, so they make all the mattresses there and they’ll ship directly to your door.

    Next up is does the Brooklyn Sedona need a box spring. The answer is no. The mattress is actually designed to work on pretty much any foundation, like a sletted bed frame.

    If you do have a box spring that you really like or you just feel more comfortable using a box spring, feel free to do so, but you do not need one.

    Last but not least is the Brooklyn Sedona a flippable mattress and the answer is no because of the way that the layers are set up – the comfort layers are on top and the support base is on the bottom.

    If you are worried about wearing out your mattress, be sure to rotate your mattress 180 degrees every six months.

    Pros & Cons

    Before I end the review, I do want to give you my pros and cons for the Brooklyn Sedona.

    First up I think it would be a good choice for you if you are a side sleeper. It has that nice softer feel, it’s going to really help with side sleeping, spinal alignment and also help you avoid pressure points at the shoulders and the hips.

    This takes me to my next point. It’s a really great choice for those that are suffering from shoulder pain because it does have that really tall foam section on top that’s going to allow you to sink in, not going to get that jammed up feeling at the shoulders.

    The breathable coil system allows heat to escape the mattress core, giving the Sedona overall excellent temperature regulation.

    And finally I was really impressed with this ability to isolate motion transfers. So if you do share your mattress with a sleeper, their motion on their side of the bed shouldn’t wake you up in the middle of the night.

    Some of my Brooklyn Sedona complaints are that I don’t think it’s a good choice of mattress for stomach sleepers, just because it does have a bit of a softer feel to the mattress.

    I generally do not like soft mattresses for stomach sleepers because it puts your back in a bad position.

    I also don’t think it’s a great choice for heavier folks out there. So if you’re in that 250 plus pound range, I don’t think that’s gonna have the proper support for you.


    The Sedona hybrid mattress comes in all six standard mattress sizes, as well as some less common options, including the full XL, short queen, and split California King.


    If you are interested in purchasing the Sedona mattress, I want to give you some of Brooklyn Beding’s policies.

    There is a 120-night trial period, so you can have it in your home for about four months, deciding whether you want to keep it or send it back.

    Shipping is for free and it will arrive compressed in a box, so you want to let it decompress for a few hours or overnight before you get the full support and feel of the mattress.

    And finally, Brooklyn Bedding offers a 10 year warranty on this mattress.


    Since they often have promotions, it’s best to check the latest price on their site.

    That’s it for my review of the Brooklyn Sedona.

    Best Affordable Mattress in a Box (Hybrid)

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *